Reland Pin -loop-reduce to legacy PMplatform-tools-31.0.3platform-tools-31.0.2platform-tools-31.0.1platform-tools-31.0.0android-vts-12.1_r9android-vts-12.1_r8android-vts-12.1_r7android-vts-12.1_r6android-vts-12.1_r5android-vts-12.1_r4android-vts-12.1_r3android-vts-12.1_r2android-vts-12.1_r10android-vts-12.1_r1android-vts-12.0_r9android-vts-12.0_r8android-vts-12.0_r7android-vts-12.0_r6android-vts-12.0_r5android-vts-12.0_r4android-vts-12.0_r3android-vts-12.0_r2android-vts-12.0_r12android-vts-12.0_r11android-vts-12.0_r10android-vts-12.0_r1android-security-12.0.0_r60android-security-12.0.0_r59android-security-12.0.0_r58android-security-12.0.0_r57android-security-12.0.0_r56android-security-12.0.0_r55android-security-12.0.0_r54android-security-12.0.0_r53android-security-12.0.0_r52android-security-12.0.0_r51android-security-12.0.0_r50android-security-12.0.0_r49android-security-12.0.0_r48android-security-12.0.0_r47android-security-12.0.0_r46android-security-12.0.0_r45android-security-12.0.0_r44android-security-12.0.0_r43android-security-12.0.0_r42android-security-12.0.0_r41android-security-12.0.0_r40android-security-12.0.0_r39android-security-12.0.0_r38android-security-12.0.0_r37android-security-12.0.0_r36android-security-12.0.0_r35android-security-12.0.0_r34android-security-11.0.0_r71android-s-preview-1android-s-beta-4android-s-beta-3android-s-beta-2android-s-beta-1android-platform-13.0.0_r17android-platform-12.1.0_r9android-platform-12.1.0_r8android-platform-12.1.0_r7android-platform-12.1.0_r6android-platform-12.1.0_r5android-platform-12.1.0_r4android-platform-12.1.0_r3android-platform-12.1.0_r28android-platform-12.1.0_r27android-platform-12.1.0_r26android-platform-12.1.0_r25android-platform-12.1.0_r24android-platform-12.1.0_r23android-platform-12.1.0_r22android-platform-12.1.0_r21android-platform-12.1.0_r20android-platform-12.1.0_r2android-platform-12.1.0_r19android-platform-12.1.0_r18android-platform-12.1.0_r17android-platform-12.1.0_r16android-platform-12.1.0_r15android-platform-12.1.0_r14android-platform-12.1.0_r13android-platform-12.1.0_r12android-platform-12.1.0_r11android-platform-12.1.0_r10android-platform-12.1.0_r1android-platform-12.0.0_r9android-platform-12.0.0_r8android-platform-12.0.0_r7android-platform-12.0.0_r6android-platform-12.0.0_r5android-platform-12.0.0_r4android-platform-12.0.0_r32android-platform-12.0.0_r31android-platform-12.0.0_r30android-platform-12.0.0_r3android-platform-12.0.0_r29android-platform-12.0.0_r28android-platform-12.0.0_r27android-platform-12.0.0_r26android-platform-12.0.0_r25android-platform-12.0.0_r24android-platform-12.0.0_r23android-platform-12.0.0_r22android-platform-12.0.0_r21android-platform-12.0.0_r20android-platform-12.0.0_r2android-platform-12.0.0_r19android-platform-12.0.0_r18android-platform-12.0.0_r17android-platform-12.0.0_r16android-platform-12.0.0_r15android-platform-12.0.0_r14android-platform-12.0.0_r13android-platform-12.0.0_r12android-platform-12.0.0_r11android-platform-12.0.0_r10android-platform-12.0.0_r1android-mainline-12.0.0_r99android-mainline-12.0.0_r98android-mainline-12.0.0_r97android-mainline-12.0.0_r96android-mainline-12.0.0_r95android-mainline-12.0.0_r94android-mainline-12.0.0_r93android-mainline-12.0.0_r92android-mainline-12.0.0_r91android-mainline-12.0.0_r90android-mainline-12.0.0_r9android-mainline-12.0.0_r89android-mainline-12.0.0_r88android-mainline-12.0.0_r87android-mainline-12.0.0_r86android-mainline-12.0.0_r85android-mainline-12.0.0_r84android-mainline-12.0.0_r83android-mainline-12.0.0_r82android-mainline-12.0.0_r81android-mainline-12.0.0_r80android-mainline-12.0.0_r8android-mainline-12.0.0_r79android-mainline-12.0.0_r78android-mainline-12.0.0_r77android-mainline-12.0.0_r76android-mainline-12.0.0_r75android-mainline-12.0.0_r74android-mainline-12.0.0_r73android-mainline-12.0.0_r72android-mainline-12.0.0_r71android-mainline-12.0.0_r70android-mainline-12.0.0_r7android-mainline-12.0.0_r69android-mainline-12.0.0_r68android-mainline-12.0.0_r67android-mainline-12.0.0_r66android-mainline-12.0.0_r65android-mainline-12.0.0_r64android-mainline-12.0.0_r63android-mainline-12.0.0_r62android-mainline-12.0.0_r61android-mainline-12.0.0_r60android-mainline-12.0.0_r6android-mainline-12.0.0_r59android-mainline-12.0.0_r58android-mainline-12.0.0_r57android-mainline-12.0.0_r56android-mainline-12.0.0_r53android-mainline-12.0.0_r52android-mainline-12.0.0_r51android-mainline-12.0.0_r50android-mainline-12.0.0_r5android-mainline-12.0.0_r49android-mainline-12.0.0_r48android-mainline-12.0.0_r47android-mainline-12.0.0_r46android-mainline-12.0.0_r45android-mainline-12.0.0_r44android-mainline-12.0.0_r43android-mainline-12.0.0_r42android-mainline-12.0.0_r41android-mainline-12.0.0_r40android-mainline-12.0.0_r4android-mainline-12.0.0_r39android-mainline-12.0.0_r38android-mainline-12.0.0_r37android-mainline-12.0.0_r36android-mainline-12.0.0_r35android-mainline-12.0.0_r34android-mainline-12.0.0_r33android-mainline-12.0.0_r32android-mainline-12.0.0_r31android-mainline-12.0.0_r30android-mainline-12.0.0_r3android-mainline-12.0.0_r29android-mainline-12.0.0_r28android-mainline-12.0.0_r27android-mainline-12.0.0_r26android-mainline-12.0.0_r25android-mainline-12.0.0_r24android-mainline-12.0.0_r23android-mainline-12.0.0_r22android-mainline-12.0.0_r21android-mainline-12.0.0_r20android-mainline-12.0.0_r2android-mainline-12.0.0_r19android-mainline-12.0.0_r18android-mainline-12.0.0_r17android-mainline-12.0.0_r16android-mainline-12.0.0_r15android-mainline-12.0.0_r14android-mainline-12.0.0_r13android-mainline-12.0.0_r126android-mainline-12.0.0_r125android-mainline-12.0.0_r124android-mainline-12.0.0_r123android-mainline-12.0.0_r122android-mainline-12.0.0_r121android-mainline-12.0.0_r120android-mainline-12.0.0_r12android-mainline-12.0.0_r119android-mainline-12.0.0_r118android-mainline-12.0.0_r117android-mainline-12.0.0_r116android-mainline-12.0.0_r115android-mainline-12.0.0_r114android-mainline-12.0.0_r113android-mainline-12.0.0_r110android-mainline-12.0.0_r11android-mainline-12.0.0_r109android-mainline-12.0.0_r108android-mainline-12.0.0_r107android-mainline-12.0.0_r106android-mainline-12.0.0_r105android-mainline-12.0.0_r104android-mainline-12.0.0_r103android-mainline-12.0.0_r102android-mainline-12.0.0_r101android-mainline-12.0.0_r100android-mainline-12.0.0_r10android-mainline-12.0.0_r1android-cts-12.1_r9android-cts-12.1_r8android-cts-12.1_r7android-cts-12.1_r6android-cts-12.1_r5android-cts-12.1_r4android-cts-12.1_r3android-cts-12.1_r2android-cts-12.1_r10android-cts-12.1_r1android-cts-12.0_r9android-cts-12.0_r8android-cts-12.0_r7android-cts-12.0_r6android-cts-12.0_r5android-cts-12.0_r4android-cts-12.0_r3android-cts-12.0_r2android-cts-12.0_r12android-cts-12.0_r11android-cts-12.0_r10android-cts-12.0_r1android-12.1.0_r9android-12.1.0_r8android-12.1.0_r7android-12.1.0_r6android-12.1.0_r5android-12.1.0_r4android-12.1.0_r3android-12.1.0_r27android-12.1.0_r26android-12.1.0_r25android-12.1.0_r24android-12.1.0_r23android-12.1.0_r22android-12.1.0_r21android-12.1.0_r20android-12.1.0_r2android-12.1.0_r19android-12.1.0_r18android-12.1.0_r17android-12.1.0_r16android-12.1.0_r15android-12.1.0_r14android-12.1.0_r13android-12.1.0_r12android-12.1.0_r11android-12.1.0_r10android-12.1.0_r1android-12.0.0_r9android-12.0.0_r8android-12.0.0_r7android-12.0.0_r6android-12.0.0_r5android-12.0.0_r4android-12.0.0_r34android-12.0.0_r33android-12.0.0_r32android-12.0.0_r31android-12.0.0_r30android-12.0.0_r3android-12.0.0_r29android-12.0.0_r28android-12.0.0_r27android-12.0.0_r26android-12.0.0_r25android-12.0.0_r21android-12.0.0_r20android-12.0.0_r2android-12.0.0_r19android-12.0.0_r18android-12.0.0_r16android-12.0.0_r15android-12.0.0_r14android-12.0.0_r13android-12.0.0_r12android-12.0.0_r11android-12.0.0_r10android-12.0.0_r1aml_wif_311811030aml_tz3_314012070aml_tz3_314012050aml_tz3_314012010aml_tz3_313110000aml_tz3_312511020aml_tz3_312511010aml_tz3_312410020aml_tz3_312410010aml_tz3_311312010aml_tet_311811050aml_sdk_311710000aml_pco_311011000aml_mpr_311911090aml_doc_310851020temp_RQ2A.210305.007simpleperf-releasesdk-releasemain-cg-testing-releasemain-b-319914597b282931628-mainandroid12L-tests-releaseandroid12L-s1-releaseandroid12L-releaseandroid12L-platform-releaseandroid12L-gsiandroid12L-devandroid12L-d2-s8-releaseandroid12L-d2-s7-releaseandroid12L-d2-s6-releaseandroid12L-d2-s5-releaseandroid12L-d2-s4-releaseandroid12L-d2-s3-releaseandroid12L-d2-s2-releaseandroid12L-d2-s1-releaseandroid12L-d2-releaseandroid12-tests-releaseandroid12-security-releaseandroid12-s5-releaseandroid12-s4-releaseandroid12-s3-releaseandroid12-s2-releaseandroid12-s1-releaseandroid12-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s7-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s6-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s5-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s4-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s3-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s2-releaseandroid12-qpr3-s1-releaseandroid12-qpr3-releaseandroid12-qpr1-releaseandroid12-qpr1-d-s3-releaseandroid12-qpr1-d-s2-releaseandroid12-qpr1-d-s1-releaseandroid12-qpr1-d-releaseandroid12-platform-releaseandroid12-mainline-wifi-releaseandroid12-mainline-tzdata3-releaseandroid12-mainline-tethering-releaseandroid12-mainline-statsd-releaseandroid12-mainline-sdkext-releaseandroid12-mainline-resolv-releaseandroid12-mainline-permission-releaseandroid12-mainline-neuralnetworks-releaseandroid12-mainline-networkstack-releaseandroid12-mainline-mediaprovider-releaseandroid12-mainline-media-swcodec-releaseandroid12-mainline-media-releaseandroid12-mainline-ipsec-releaseandroid12-mainline-extservices-releaseandroid12-mainline-documentsui-releaseandroid12-mainline-conscrypt-releaseandroid12-mainline-cellbroadcast-releaseandroid12-mainline-captiveportallogin-releaseandroid12-mainline-art-releaseandroid12-mainline-adbd-releaseandroid12-gsiandroid12-devandroid12-d1-s6-releaseandroid12-d1-s5-releaseandroid12-d1-s4-releaseandroid12-d1-s3-releaseandroid12-d1-s2-releaseandroid12-d1-s1-releaseandroid12-d1-releaseandroid12--mainline-releaseandroid-s-beta-4aml_tz3_314012010

This was accidentally reverted by a later change.

LSR currently only runs in the codegen pass manager.
There are a couple issues with LSR and the NPM.
1) Lots of tests assume that LCSSA isn't run before LSR. This breaks a
bunch of tests' expected output. This is fixable with some time put in.
2) LSR doesn't preserve LCSSA. See
llvm/test/Analysis/MemorySSA/update-remove-deadblocks.ll. LSR's use of
SCEVExpander is the only use of SCEVExpander where the PreserveLCSSA option is
off. Turning it on causes some code sinking out of loops to fail due to
SCEVExpander's inability to handle the newly created trivial PHI nodes in the
broken critical edge (I was looking at
llvm/test/Transforms/LoopStrengthReduce/X86/2011-11-29-postincphi.ll).
I also tried simply just calling formLCSSA() at the end of LSR, but the extra
PHI nodes cause regressions in codegen tests.

We'll delay figuring these issues out until later.

This causes the number of check-llvm failures with -enable-new-pm true
by default to go from 60 to 29.

Reviewed By: asbirlea

Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D92796

1 files changed, 2 insertions, 1 deletions

diff --git a/llvm/tools/opt/opt.cpp b/llvm/tools/opt/opt.cpp
index 276fab73650b..ad9dc2d0774a 100644
--- a/llvm/tools/opt/opt.cpp
+++ b/llvm/tools/opt/opt.cpp
@@ -485,7 +485,8 @@ static bool shouldPinPassToLegacyPM(StringRef Pass) {
                                           "expand-reductions",
                                           "indirectbr-expand",
                                           "generic-to-nvvm",
-                                          "expandmemcmp"};
+                                          "expandmemcmp",
+                                          "loop-reduce"};
   for (const auto &P : PassNamePrefix)
     if (Pass.startswith(P))
       return true;